17 Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

Jump to recipe

Thanksgiving is a very special time of year for Americans. It’s a time to sit down with family and enjoy a delicious, extravagant dinner.

But no Thanksgiving dinner is complete without a delicious selection of pies. There’s lots of different pies out there to choose from; with so many options, how can you choose?

To help you make your decision, we’ve wrangled together seventeen of the best pie recipes for Thanksgiving. These pies will surely hit the spot!

17 Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

Making a great Thanksgiving pie takes time, so we recommend you get straight into our list! There’s definitely a pie here for everyone.

1. Pumpkin Pie

Of course, we have to start with the essential pie recipes! Pumpkin pie is such a classic Thanksgiving pie recipe that it just has to be on anyone’s radar.

While not everyone is a fan of pumpkin pie, there’s plenty of people out there who enjoy it! It became popular for a reason, you know. Plus, it’s pretty easy to make- so beginner pie makers, don’t fear!

Here’s a tasty recipe: https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/the-great-pumpkin-pie-recipe/

2. Apple Pie

Another classic pie recipe is apple pie. A great apple pie recipe is the perfect blend of sweet and tart, crunchy and chewy. Apple pie is the pinnacle of fall comfort desserts!

There’s lots of different options for what types of apples work best in apple pie. Stick to what the recipe recommends, or consider experimenting and seeing what works best for you!

Need a delicious recipe? Check this one out: https://natashaskitchen.com/apple-pie-recipe/

3. Sweet Potato Pie

If you aren’t already serving sweet potatoes as part of the main course, consider serving some sweet potato pie for dessert!

This pie is going to be more savory than sweet, so if you or your guests are the type without sweet teeth, this is definitely the right choice. Plus, it’s unique; not a lot of people consider serving sweet potatoes as part of dessert!

Check out this awesome recipe: https://www.cookingclassy.com/sweet-potato-pie/

4. Pecan Pie

There might be some debate about how to pronounce “pecan”, but there’s certainly no debate over the deliciousness of this pie!

Done right, pecan pie can be an excellent choice for your Thanksgiving dessert offering. For anyone on your guest list who loves sweet pies and nuts, there’s no going wrong with this one.

Want a great pecan pie recipe? We’ve found one here: https://cookiesandcups.com/easy-pecan-pie-recipe/

5. Rocky Road Pie

If cream pies are your kind of thing, we’ve got you! The main ingredients of this pie are chocolate, peanuts, and marshmallow. Sound like something that’ll satisfy your sweet tooth? We bet!

Of course, you’ve got to have some whipped cream on hand to slather on top of this pie. This pie will likely be super popular with kids, but we’re sure any age can come to appreciate this fluffy wonder!

Check out this unique recipe here: https://www.recipegirl.com/rocky-road-pie/

6. Apple-Cheddar Pie

If apple pie is too boring or sweet for your liking, then try out some apple-cheddar pie! This pie combines the sweet flavors of a typical apple pie with the savory flavors of good cheese to create something truly magnificent.

Imagine your guests’ surprise when you tell them that this isn’t any ordinary apple pie- it has cheese in it! It might sound a bit odd to you at first, but we definitely recommend you try it out.

Want to try out this truly unique pie? We’ve found a recipe for you here: https://www.cabotcheese.coop/recipe/apple-pie-with-cheddar-cheese/

7. Lemon Meringue Pie

Sweet and salty might not be a descriptor that comes to mind right away when you think about what sounds good in a Thanksgiving pie. But that’s how we’ve seen lemon meringue pie described- and we think it fits.

We’d encourage you to be bold in selecting your Thanksgiving pies! Lemon meringue might not be the first choice that comes to mind, but it’s certainly something we think your guests will love.

Find a delicious recipe here: https://preppykitchen.com/lemon-meringue-pie/

8. Chocolate Cream Pie

Some people aren’t fans of marshmallow, and a good amount of people out there are allergic to peanuts. Rocky Road pie wouldn’t be for either of these types of people; but there’s a great alternative that’s just as chocolatey!

Enter chocolate cream pie. Simpler than Rocky Road but still just as delicious, this pie will be a grand slam for your Thanksgiving meal. It’s not too complicated to make, either, which is a great bonus!

Find a cool recipe here: https://tastesbetterfromscratch.com/chocolate-cream-pie/

9. Pear Pie

While the first fruit that’s going to come to mind for most is apple when talking about Thanksgiving pies, we really encourage you to consider other types of fruits, too!

Pear pie is definitely going to be on the tarter side in comparison to apple, but there’s plenty of people out there who appreciate a tart pie. If you’re sick of apple pie, but still want some kind of fruit pie at your Thanksgiving, give pear pie a shot.

Want to try out this pie? We’ve found a great recipe for you here: https://carlsbadcravings.com/pear-pie/

10. Butterscotch Pie

Chocolate lovers abound, but butterscotch is a perfectly viable alternative! We think butterscotch is highly underappreciated; that definitely needs to change. Move over chocolate, butterscotch wants the spotlight.

If you’re a fan of Butterfingers, then there’s a good chance you’ll like this pie. Plus, it’s unique; that’s perfect for anyone who really wants to keep things fresh and exciting at their Thanksgiving.

Try out this epic recipe: https://handletheheat.com/butterscotch-pie/

11. Bourbon and Chocolate Pecan Pie

Alright, so regular pecan pie is too boring for you? We get it. Not everyone is satisfied with the basics; we’ve got you! Bourbon and chocolate pecan pie is the perfect way to add brand new dimensions to an already-great pie.

This pie is truly going to blow both yourself and your guests out of the water. Imagine how impressed everyone will be that you managed to come up with something so creative! No need to tell them you got it off a list.

Try out this amazing pie by using this recipe: https://bromabakery.com/bourbon-chocolate-pecan-pie/

12. Cranberry Pie

Instead of serving cranberry in your main course, why not move it to dessert? Putting cranberries in a pie isn’t something that’s super common, but we definitely think you should at least consider it.

This is an absolutely gorgeous pie; you might forget to even eat it after you cut into it, because you’re too busy staring at it! The bright colors and unique taste make cranberry pie worth a try.

Check out a recipe for cranberry pie here: https://www.bakedbyanintrovert.com/cranberry-pie/

13. Cherry Pie

In comparison to other fruit pies on this list, cherry pie might be one you’ve had before. It’s fairly common, especially if you live in an area where cherries are grown in large quantities. Sure, it’s nowhere near as popular as apple pie, but no fruit pie really comes close to that one!

This isn’t too far of a leap from cherry cobbler, which a lot of people have had. So, if you’re the type of person who enjoys a good cherry cobbler, give this a try the next time you’re in charge of procuring a Thanksgiving pie.

Make this awesome fruit pie by using the recipe here: https://natashaskitchen.com/classic-cherry-pie-recipe/

14. Grape Pie

Now here’s a pie that few people realize exists, let alone who have tried it! This pie is especially popular in areas of the country where grapes are grown in large quantities. It’s certainly an unusual option, but it’s one that’ll have people talking!

There’s different approaches you can take to making grape pie, including putting an oat topping on it. Do what feels the best for you and what you think your guests will enjoy the most!

Try out this unique recipe: https://www.mamagourmand.com/concord-grape-pie/

15. Coconut Cream Pie

Lots of people like coconut cream pie! It’s a great way to introduce yourself to cream pies, especially if you’re not the biggest chocolate person.

This can be a bit of a challenge to make, so we don’t necessarily recommend this pie for beginners. However, if you feel you’re up for the challenge, then what’s stopping you? Go ahead and take on this amazing pie!

We’ve found a perfect recipe for you here: https://addapinch.com/coconut-cream-pie-recipe/

16. Blueberry Pie

Opinions are sometimes quite divided on this pie; it really seems to be one that people either love or hate. If you’re in the “love” camp, or you haven’t yet given this fruit pie a chance, we definitely recommend it!

This could be a bit of a risky pie to serve for Thanksgiving, but we certainly think it’s worth it. Plenty of people appreciate all that this fruit pie has to offer; besides, who said taking risks is always a bad thing?

Want to try blueberry pie? Take a look at this recipe here: https://sugarapron.com/2020/06/03/easy-blueberry-pie/

17. Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

For our last suggestion, we’ve got a pie that’s sure to satisfy even the strongest sweet tooth out there! Peanut butter chocolate pie is certainly not for the faint of heart, but it’s absolutely delicious!

If there’s anyone on your guest list who is always on the hunt for the sweetest desserts they can find, this will certainly satisfy them. Give this amazing pie a try next Thanksgiving!

Try this incredibly sweet pie by using this recipe: https://chefsavvy.com/chocolate-peanut-butter-pie/

Wrap-Up

And so, we’ve finished our list of seventeen amazing Thanksgiving pie recipes. We’ve tried to come up with as many different options as possible for all types of taste! Remember- don’t be afraid to do the unexpected! Happy Thanksgiving!

Leave a Reply